Free MCAT prep › MCAT CARS practice passage
Free MCAT CARS practice passage
An original, MCAT-style Critical Analysis and Reasoning Skills passage with seven questions. Set a 10-minute timer, answer every question, then open the explanations, which cover why each wrong option is wrong.
Social sciences · Economics · 551 words · 7 questions · about 10 minutes
The tragedy of the commons revisited
¶1In 1968 the ecologist Garrett Hardin published an essay that would become one of the most cited in the social sciences. He asked readers to picture a pasture open to all. Each herder gains the full benefit of adding one more animal, while the cost of the extra grazing is shared among everyone who uses the field. Reasoning this way, every herder keeps adding animals, and the pasture is ruined. Hardin called the result “the tragedy of the commons,” using tragedy in its old sense of an outcome that unfolds with grim inevitability. Freedom in a commons, he concluded, brings ruin to all; the remedy lay in private property or in coercive regulation, what he called “mutual coercion, mutually agreed upon.”
¶2The parable proved enormously persuasive, partly because it seemed to need no evidence. It followed from assumptions about individual self-interest that many economists already held, and it appeared to explain a great deal: depleted fisheries, overgrazed rangelands, polluted rivers. Yet as a description of how people have actually managed shared resources, it was strikingly incomplete. Hardin’s herders never speak to one another. They make no agreements, keep no watch on one another, and impose no penalties. They are less a community than a set of strangers who happen to share a field.
¶3The political economist Elinor Ostrom spent much of her career studying what happens when the herders do talk. In Swiss alpine villages, in irrigation systems in Spain and the Philippines, and in coastal fisheries in Turkey, she found communities that had sustained common resources for generations, sometimes for centuries, without either dividing them into private holdings or handing them to a distant government. The arrangements varied, but certain features recurred. The boundaries of the resource and the membership of the group were clearly defined. Those who used the resource helped write the rules. Monitoring was done by users themselves or by people answerable to them, and penalties began small and grew with repeated offenses. The work earned her a share of the 2009 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.
¶4It would be easy to read this research as a simple refutation of Hardin, and some of Ostrom’s admirers have done so, treating the commons as a model of cooperation that markets and states have needlessly disrupted. That reading misses her point. The successful commons she documented were not spontaneous. They were institutions, built slowly and maintained with effort, and many attempts to build them failed. Ostrom did not show that shared resources take care of themselves. She showed that Hardin had mistaken one possible outcome, the one that follows when users cannot communicate or enforce agreements, for the only possible one.
¶5This correction matters most where it is least comforting. The features Ostrom identified are easiest to achieve in small groups with stable membership, a resource whose condition they can observe, and the authority to set their own rules. The most pressing commons of the present, such as the atmosphere and the open ocean, have none of these. Their users number in the billions, and the damage each user does is invisible to the others. Nothing in Ostrom’s findings guarantees that institutions able to manage such resources can be built. What her findings do establish is that the question is one of institutional design, not of human nature.
Questions
1. Which of the following best expresses the central thesis of the passage?
- A. Ostrom refuted Hardin by showing that shared resources tend to sustain themselves.
- B. Hardin’s reasoning was sound, so only privatization or state control can save common resources.
- C. Ruin is one possible fate of a commons, and avoiding it requires designed institutions.
- D. Hardin’s tragedy fails for small local commons but holds for global ones.
Show answer and explanations
Answer: C · Comprehension · evidence in ¶4, ¶5
A · Reversed: ¶4: this is the admirers’ reading the author rejects; the commons she found “were not spontaneous.”
B · Reversed: ¶2–3 argue Hardin’s account was incomplete; Ostrom found commons sustained without either remedy.
C (correct): ¶4: Hardin mistook one possible outcome for the only one; ¶5: the question is one of institutional design.
D · Half right: ¶5 says global commons lack Ostrom’s favorable conditions, but not that ruin is inevitable; it is still a question of design.
2. Which of the following does the passage identify as features of the commons Ostrom studied?
I. Membership was widened over time to admit newcomers.
II. The users of a resource took part in making its rules.
III. Use was monitored by the users or by people answerable to them.
- A. II only
- B. I and II only
- C. II and III only
- D. I, II and III
Show answer and explanations
Answer: C · Comprehension · evidence in ¶3
A · Half right: II is a feature, but so is III.
B · Out of scope: I is not in the passage, which says membership was clearly defined.
C (correct): ¶3: users helped write the rules, and monitoring was done by users or people answerable to them.
D · Out of scope: I is never mentioned; ¶3 stresses clearly defined membership.
3. The author’s remark that Hardin’s herders “are less a community than a set of strangers” (paragraph 2) serves mainly to:
- A. identify the unrealistic assumption that limits the parable’s reach.
- B. suggest that rural herders were especially unlikely to trust one another.
- C. show that Hardin misunderstood the economics of grazing livestock.
- D. argue that self-interest plays no role in how people use shared land.
Show answer and explanations
Answer: A · Reasoning within · evidence in ¶2
A (correct): ¶2: the parable is incomplete because its herders never communicate, agree or enforce; ¶3 then shows what happens when they do.
B · Out of scope: The remark describes Hardin’s imagined herders, not the trustworthiness of real ones.
C · Out of scope: The author faults the missing communication, not Hardin’s grasp of grazing economics.
D · Too extreme: The author never denies self-interest; the point is that people can also make and enforce agreements.
4. In paragraph 4, the author’s main point about some of Ostrom’s admirers is that they:
- A. rightly see her work as proof that markets harm shared resources.
- B. ignore her evidence from irrigation systems in favor of fisheries.
- C. accept Hardin’s parable while rejecting Ostrom’s proposed remedies.
- D. overstate her findings by treating successful commons as self-sustaining.
Show answer and explanations
Answer: D · Reasoning within · evidence in ¶4
A · Reversed: The author calls this reading a mistake: “That reading misses her point.”
B · Out of scope: The passage says nothing about which of her cases the admirers emphasize.
C · Reversed: The admirers reject Hardin; they treat her work as refuting him.
D (correct): ¶4: they read the work as a simple refutation, but the commons she studied “were not spontaneous” and did not “take care of themselves.”
5. Fishers in a coastal town have long shared a bay without formal rules, and catches are now falling. Based on the passage, which step would Ostrom’s findings most support?
- A. Having the fishers agree on catch limits and appoint their own monitors.
- B. Selling exclusive fishing rights in the bay to a single company.
- C. Waiting for the fishers’ self-interest to restore the fish stocks naturally.
- D. Leaving catch limits to a regional agency that the fishers may petition.
Show answer and explanations
Answer: A · Reasoning beyond · evidence in ¶3, ¶4
A (correct): ¶3: successful commons had users who helped write the rules and monitored themselves.
B · Reversed: Privatization is Hardin’s remedy; Ostrom’s cases succeeded without dividing the resource into private holdings.
C · Reversed: ¶4: commons are not spontaneous; they need institutions built with effort.
D · Half right: Limits help, but ¶3’s successful commons had users write the rules and monitor themselves, not petition an outside body.
6. Which finding, if true, would most weaken the author’s claim in paragraph 5 that the fate of a commons is a question of institutional design?
- A. Several small fishing villages kept their grounds healthy for centuries using local rules.
- B. Agreements among nations have reduced some kinds of atmospheric pollution.
- C. Commons with similar users and resources fare the same whatever rules they adopt.
- D. Hardin’s essay remains among the most cited works in the social sciences.
Show answer and explanations
Answer: C · Reasoning beyond · evidence in ¶5
A · Reversed: This supports the claim: local rules sustained the resource.
B · Reversed: This supports the claim by suggesting institutions can work even for a global commons.
C (correct): If outcomes do not depend on the rules adopted, design cannot be what decides a commons’ fate.
D · Out of scope: How often the essay is cited says nothing about what determines a commons’ fate.
7. Which situation is most analogous to the relationship the author sees between Hardin’s parable and Ostrom’s findings?
- A. A new medicine is shown to work better than an older one in trials.
- B. A theory of markets is confirmed by data from many different countries.
- C. A historian proves that a famous battle never actually took place.
- D. A model of drivers who cannot signal is taken to describe all traffic.
Show answer and explanations
Answer: D · Reasoning beyond · evidence in ¶4
A · Out of scope: Nothing here concerns a special case mistaken for a general rule.
B · Reversed: Confirmation is the opposite of what Ostrom’s findings did to Hardin’s parable.
C · Too extreme: The author says Ostrom did not simply refute Hardin; his outcome remains one real possibility.
D (correct): ¶4: Hardin generalized the case where users cannot communicate into the only possible outcome; the analogy mirrors that overreach.
The labels on wrong answers name the trap: Too extreme overstates the passage, Reversed says the opposite, Out of scope brings in something the passage never addresses, Half right starts correctly and then goes wrong, and Too literal misreads a figure of speech.
Want more passages like this? Quanta Premium includes a growing bank of original CARS passages with timed exam mode, highlighting, cross-outs and evidence-linked review.
Get Quanta free